The 6 best eyelash curlers of 2026, by eye shape
Six eyelash curlers sold on Amazon, from a drugstore classic to the Japanese-made favorites, matched to eye shape and with a plain note on replacing the pad.
By the editorsUpdated 5 min read
How we chose: This is a research roundup. We compared formulas, finishes, shade ranges and what buyers report after weeks of use. It isn't a hands-on test, and we'll say so in the post when we've tried something ourselves.
If you buy through our links we may earn a commission. It never decides what we recommend. How we make money
The best eyelash curler is the one that fits your eye. A curler that is too curved for a flat lid pinches the corners and leaves a crimp. One that is too flat for a rounder eye misses the outer lashes.
We sorted six popular curlers by the eye shapes buyers say they suit, and we note when the pad needs replacing, because that is what makes a curler stop working.
Quick picks
- Best overall: Shiseido Eyelash Curler
- Best budget: Revlon Eyelash Curler
- Best for round or deep-set eyes: Tweezerman ProCurl Lash Curler
- Best for a deeper curve: Kevyn Aucoin The Eyelash Curler
- Best for a comfortable grip: Surratt Beauty Relevee Lash Curler
- Best splurge: Shu Uemura Eyelash Curler
How we picked
This is a research roundup. We haven't used these curlers. We looked at the shape of each one, the pad material, whether replacement pads are easy to find, and what buyers and makeup artists say about fit, pinching and how long the pad lasts. Several brands market their curler as one-shape-fits-all. We took that with a pinch of salt, because buyer reviews say otherwise.
We left out heated curlers, which can be harsh on lashes, and anything with no clear way to replace the pad.
The best eyelash curlers of 2026
Best overallShiseido
1. Eyelash Curler
A long-time favorite with a relatively flat shape that buyers say suits almond and monolid eyes. Replacement pads are sold separately by Shiseido, though some Amazon sellers ship them from overseas.
Skip it if your eyes are very round or deep-set. A flatter curve can miss the outer lashes.
Best for: Almond and monolid eyesCheck price on Amazon
Best for round or deep-set eyesTweezerman
2. ProCurl Lash Curler
A stainless-steel curler with silicone pads and an angled design the brand says fits every eye shape. Buyers with round and large eyes often say it is gentle and doesn't pinch.
Skip it if you have a flat lid or a monolid. Some buyers with almond eyes report it can feel narrow.
Best for: Round, deep-set eyesCheck price on Amazon
Best for a deeper curveKevyn Aucoin
3. The Eyelash Curler
A stainless-steel curler with a curved frame and a silicone pad. Reviewers like how easy it is to see the lash line, and say it gets all the lashes without pinching.
Skip it if your lashes are short or sparse. The deeper curve can feel like a lot for a small lash line.
Best for: A deeper curlCheck price on Amazon
Best for a comfortable gripSurratt Beauty
4. Relevee Lash Curler
A hand-calibrated curler with a matte grip and silicone pads. Buyers like how it holds. The most common complaint is that the pad wears out, so keep a spare.
Skip it if you want an easy-to-replace pad. Several reviewers say spares are hard to find.
Best for: Comfortable gripCheck price on Amazon
Best budgetRevlon
5. Eyelash Curler
The drugstore classic. A basic metal curler that does the job at the lowest cost, but with a more general shape than the others here.
Skip it if you have very flat, wide or monolid eyes. A basic shape can pinch.
Best for: Budget curlingCheck price on Amazon
Best splurgeShu Uemura
6. Eyelash Curler
A curler reviewers often call a favorite, and one test ranked first. Fit is a common sticking point. Buyers disagree on fit and on how easy refills are, so check before you buy.
Skip it if you have almond eyes. Some buyers say it did not fit their eye shape.
Best for: A classic splurgeCheck price on Amazon
How to choose an eyelash curler
Start with your eye shape. These are rules of thumb, not guarantees, because the same curler suits different people.
Round or deep-set eyes. A curler with a rounder, deeper curve usually follows the lid better, so the lashes at the outer corner get curled too. Tweezerman's ProCurl is the one buyers with round eyes mention most.
Almond eyes. Most curlers work. A flatter curve such as Shiseido's gives a gentle lift. A deeper one such as Kevyn Aucoin's gives a more dramatic curl.
Hooded or monolid eyes. A flatter curve tends to work better, because there is less lid to sit against. Take care not to catch the skin. If a curler pinches, stop. A different shape is the answer, not more pressure.
Pad replacement
The pad is the part that wears out first. Over time it flattens and cracks, and the curler starts to crimp lashes or pull them. Change it when you see a dent, a crack or a tear, and sooner if you notice kinks. Many guides suggest every few months for regular use, but how long yours lasts depends on how often you curl.
Before you buy, check whether replacement pads are sold for that exact model, and keep a spare. This is where the picks differ most. Shiseido sells its own pads, and Tweezerman and Kevyn Aucoin come with silicone pads. For Surratt and Shu Uemura, buyers say spares can be harder to find, so check the listing.
Technique
Curl before mascara, never after, since curling over mascara can make lashes stick to the pad and break. Clamp at the base and hold for a few seconds. Then move up the lash in two or three squeezes for a smoother curve. If you like a more natural result, don't skip the middle step.
Questions people ask
What is the best eyelash curler for hooded eyes?
A flatter curve usually works better, because there is less room against the lid. Shiseido's curler is often named for hooded and monolid eyes. If a curler pinches your skin, it does not fit.
How often should you replace the pad on an eyelash curler?
When it is dented, cracked or hard, which for many people is every few months with regular use. A worn pad crimps lashes. Check the pad before the curler.
Do eyelash curlers damage lashes?
A well-fitted curler used gently should not. Problems usually come from curling over mascara, squeezing too hard, or using a worn pad. If you are losing lashes or your eyelids are red and sore, stop and see a doctor.
Is a heated eyelash curler better?
Some people like them. We left them out. Heat near your eyes adds risk, and we would rather you spend on a well-fitted standard curler.
If you are building a lash routine, our best drugstore mascaras pair with any of these, and the minimalist makeup bag shows where a curler fits.
Save it for later
Pin this so you have the list next time you're shopping.
